How to Sell Redemption Cards

As new sets like Topps Update continue to hit shelves and some of its best pulls aren't actually cards yet. Here's what to do with your redemption cards.
Imagine pulling a 2011 Topps Update Mike Trout rookie in 2026. “I’m literally shaking.”
Now imagine seeing its scratch-off code.
That's the reality for collectors lucky enough to hit one of this year's buyback redemptions. The best cards to chase in new sets like 2026 Topps Update include redemptions for an original 2011 Update Trout rookie and a 2018 Update Shohei Ohtani rookie, sitting alongside Golden Mirror autographs of Konnor Griffin, Ohtani, Kevin McGonigle, and JJ Wetherholt.
These are undoubtedly great pulls. They’re also confusing to sell. Let's wipe the dust off the plate and get the next batter up.
What Is a Redemption Card, Anyway?
In short, a redemption card is a placeholder for a soon-to-be-signed card.
Topps is constantly rushing to meet production deadlines, matching printed cardboard to demand revolving around the start of new MLB, NBA, and NFL seasons, among others. When Topps and an athlete have agreed to signing cards, but are unable to do so before the ship date, Topps inserts a redemption card. All you have to do is scratch off the silver covering, enter the code underneath into your account on Topps.com, and Topps mails you the real thing when it’s ready.
How Long Does a Redemption Take?
Per Topps' redemption program, you should allow up to 15 weeks (!) for processing. If the card still isn't available after that, you can request a substitute worth the card's current market value. After six months, that rises to 200% of market value in cards or Topps.com credit—and major delays like this aren’t uncommon.
The other issue is that redemptions aren’t valid forever.
Thankfully, for products from 2021-22 and later, codes are valid for 10 years. However, others from earlier releases have already expired, so buyer (and seller) beware.
Additionally, every code can only be used once, so sellers need to ensure they’re careful not to share it before an order is completed to avoid being scammed out of their pull.
Should You Redeem a Redemption Card Before Selling It or Sell It As-Is?
It depends on the card—and on your patience.
Redeem it: If the card is a long-term hold, or if you want the option of grading it. You can't slab a scratch-off code, and certain players/cards are worth holding on to, as their value can go up in the future.
Sell it as-is: If you'd rather have the money now. Unredeemed redemptions trade regularly on the secondary market, on places like eBay, and the buyer takes on the wait.
Either way, never scratch the code before you sell . A scratched code could have been entered by anyone, and buyers know it. A sealed, unscratched redemption is the only kind worth listing, and protects both buyers and sellers from getting scammed.
How Do I Price a Redemption Card?
Start with recent sales of the finished card, then decide whether or not you want to discount for the wait, or if the specific player you’re holding a redemption card is worth the wait, like a prestigious rookie or a hall of famer. Buyers are paying for a card they won't see for weeks (or months), and they're taking on the redemption risk, but a highly-coveted rookie auto can be worth that wait. Whatever you decide, be clear in your listing: clearly state the card name, card number, that this is a redemption card, and that the redemption code is unscratched.
Where Should I Sell High-End Hits Like Redemptions?
Public marketplaces are great for reach. But for a four-figure redemption, sometimes you want a smaller room full of people who know exactly what they're looking at.
That's what Mercury from inventory management and multi-channel listing platform Mascot is for. Mascot built Mercury as a private, dealer-to-dealer marketplace for verified Mascot Network sellers on Mascot’s Pro or Expert plans. Buyers can purchase cards outright or send offers (including bulk offers across several cards), and sellers can accept, decline, or counter without moving the deal into DMs. It supports raw, graded, and sealed product, and carries a low 3% seller fee.